Pages

Labels

Blog Archive

Popular Posts

Showing posts with label child protection. Show all posts
Showing posts with label child protection. Show all posts

Thursday, 16 June 2016

Inter-generational abuse by social services ?

Poppi Worthington. Photo: Rex/Shutterstock
"Health and care services overlooked the impact of `inter and multi-generational abuse` in a family where a toddler suddenly died, a serious case review has found."

"Poppi Worthington was 13-months-old when she died in December 2012. A judge found she was likely to have been sexually assaulted by her father. Her father has not been charged and denies any wrongdoing."

"The Cumbria Local Safeguarding Children Board review found Poppis family had a `complex history`. Her grandmother and mother had both been in care. Her mother was taken into care as a child due to fears of sexual exploitation. She was 27 when she became pregnant with Poppi and her twin, and had had four other children taken into care."

"The review found Poppis mother received no support for the trauma of her own experiences or the trauma of having her first child taken into care. Social care professionals worked with the mother immediately after a care order for her second child was discharged but they, as well as midwives and health visitors who worked with the mother, failed to properly consider the impact of her past, the review found."

"The report said: `There were no plans put in place for any long term support or intervention to ensure that MCN [the mother] and her children were safe and thriving despite the fact that there were several significant indicators that her capacity to parent may have been compromised by her own childhood experiences of trauma and abuse`."

"It added: `MCN had experienced significant historical traumas and loss which were, in themselves, clear indicators that her parenting may have been compromised and that her children could be at risk`."

"`There is no evidence that practitioners considered that MCN repeat pregnancies would compromise her ability to care for her children or that the repeat pregnancies were symptomatic of unresolved loss`."
 

Wednesday, 15 June 2016

What should be the role of social workers in adoption?

 
"The British Association of Social Workers (BASW) has established a UK-wide enquiry to consider the role of social work in adoption..."

"This enquiry will examine the role of the social worker in adoption, with a particular focus on how ethical issues and human rights legislation are understood and inform practice, and how these relate to pursuing good long-term outcomes for children and their families. It will gather evidence from families and young people involved in the adoption process, social workers and managers, family justice professionals, policy makers and academics using a variety of methods."

A review of child protection is to be carried out in the Highlands

"A review is to be carried out into child protection safeguards in the Highlands following the death of a two-year-old boy in Inverness."

"Clyde Campbell died in February 2014, in a case of sudden infant death, or cot death."

"His mother, Amanda Hardie, was jailed in May after admitting to neglecting him over a five month period."

"Highland Council said she refused to give her consent to work in partnership with the named person scheme."

"The Highlands is among the areas where named person has been operating ahead of it coming into force across Scotland in August."

"In a statement, Highland Council's director of care and learning, Bill Alexander, said the review would be carried out by the Highland Child Protection Committee..."

"A named person works with the consent of parents, and would have been there to support Ms Hardie, if she had been willing to work in partnership."

"However, while Ms Hardie chose not to seek support from her health visitor, other services continued to engage with her and her family."

 
We are not informed which services continued to engage with Amanda Hardie or if Clyde Campbell had a child`s plan. If he did, the Named Person would have had a role, with or without consent.
"The link to the Named Person is important as they may have information about the child and family and will know if a Childs Plan is already in place for the child. They will have a key role in contributing to any on-going planning to support the childs wellbeing."
http://www.gov.scot/Resource/0046/00465711.pdf

Saturday, 11 June 2016

Police Scotland and social work corruption

"UK Column anchor Mike Robinson is joined by guest co-presenter Patrick Henningsen to cover today key stories in Europe and internationally. Also on the program are guests analysts David Scott from Northern Exposure and Mark Anderson from American Free Press - we cover Brexit, the Bilderberg Meeting in Dresden, Bilderberg tech moguls and their new A.I. run Smart Cities, State-sanctioned child snatching north of the border, Germany, Israel shuts down the West Bank and Gaza, EU sanctions against Russia, and the historical controversy of both the Arab (semitic) and Jewish (semitic) role in the Slave Trade."
.
 
Child snatching north of the border
 
Brian Docherty uploaded a video on Youtube, April 2015, to explain his ordeal after reporting that a paedophile, who was close friends with a Viscount, had attempted to buy access to his five year old autistic son.
 
Not only did Police Scotland fail to investigate but they sent a fraudulent document to social services about the family and pursued them to Ireland where their four children were placed in foster care.
 
The children were then returned to the Docherty`s after a court hearing. That was the position over a year ago.
 
It was very sad to learn on Friday`s UK Column News that the matter had not ended there. The children were seized again and have not seen their parents for five months.
 
There will be more in depth coverage of this case next week.
 
Starts about 27 minutes into the news.
 

Friday, 10 June 2016

The `single point of contact` myth has been exploded


From Iain MacWhirter of the Herald:

"John Swinney turned the indignation meter up to 11 in his defence of the Named Person scheme in Holyrood yesterday. Critics should be `ashamed of scaremongering` he roared and `creating a climate of misinformation`. But there`s been no need for the opposition to do that. It was after all Nicola Sturgeon who said that the NP scheme was not compulsory, when it emphatically is."

"Mr Swinney added to the confusion by comparing the Named Person with a family doctor - a `service` to be accessed as Mr Swinney put it `only when the family needs it`. But GPs are not responsible for preventing child abuse. The Scottish Liberal Democrat leader, Tavish Scott, insisted that `parents and carers can say thanks, but no thanks` to a Named Person. He then contradicts himself by saying that families will `no longer be allowed to hide abuse.` Exactly."

"Child protection is not optional. This has to be made clear, whatever side you take on this issue..."

"Inevitably the shadow of two-year-old Liam Fee, who was murdered by his mothers, hung over the debate. The SNP MSP Jenny Gilruth accused the Tories of `using the death of a child to score political points`. The Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson had tweeted that Liam Fee already had a Named Person, which was half right. Fife Council admitted that Liam had indeed been assigned one as a `point of contact`. But they went on to say that this wasn`t a fully operational, all-seeing NP with all the extensive powers that go with the post."

"The trouble here is that a `point of contact` is precisely how the Government has been selling the scheme. The phrase was used repeatedly in Holyrood yesterday by MSPs. Yet it is clearly very much more than that. The SNP furiously object to the term `state guardians` but that is exactly what a Named Person is turning out to be, whether they intended this or not."

"They are appointed by the state for every single child in Scotland from the moment they are born, without exception. This is an entirely new proactive approach to child welfare that is called Getting It Right For Every Child or GIRFEC..."

"The Named Person is `a key part of the early warning system we need to make sure that every child in Scotland is protected` according to Barnardos. An early warning system only works if it has an unrestricted view. Named Persons will be expected to spot the early signs of abuse and exchange information with GPs and police - in other words to create a database in which abnormal behaviour will be monitored, recorded and assessed. This could create a bureaucracy of state intervention in family life that is unprecedented anywhere in the world."

"The responsibility on the named person will be onerous. When the next Liam Fee happens - and it certainly will happen - the finger of blame will first of all point, as it did last week to the Named Person who is suppposed to be the protector of the child."

https://twitter.com/iainmacwhirter/status/740507667425300481

Sad to say, the Liam Fee murder has brought to the surface serious questions about the Named Person scheme that are not going to go away.

As the writer makes clear, it has been the Scottish Government which has been misinforming the public about the role of Named Persons.

The Named Person scheme is much more than a `single point of contact` - it `s a surveillance system - and anybody who reads the ACT and the guidance can see that.

Meanwhile the Scottish Government intends to waste more taxpayer money inventing refreshed `spin` about it, for what they hope will be a still ignorant or gullible public.

`Digging a bigger hole` comes into mind at this point.

In order to understand the powers of the Named Person, a good place to start is with the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014, paying particular attention to Part 4.

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2014/8/contents/enacted

Whistleblower accuses Fife Council of failing Liam



On the front page of Daily Record today (10 June 2016) by James Moncur:

"Social workers had contact with Liam Fee`s killers just 24 hours before his murder - but failed to intervene to save his life."

"That is the bombshell claim by a whistleblower who accuses Fife Council of missing multiple chances to rescue the two-year-old."
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-36496523

Thursday, 9 June 2016

Review of child protection: is a joined up approach best ?

"In April 2004 the Scottish Executive published a consultation pack entitled `Getting it right for every child` as part of the first phase of the review of the Children's Hearings system."
http://www.gov.scot/Publications/2004/10/20021/44106
Out of that grew the Named Person.


Child Protection Improvement Programme

"On 25 February 2016 the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning, Angela Constance, made a statement to Parliament announcing a programme of action on child protection." This would include consideration of the "impact of changes of legislation and practice in the Children’s Hearings System."

As part of her statement she said:
"We have also modernised our unique children’s hearings system through legislation that was passed in 2011, and we have invested in professional development for social workers and all those who work with vulnerable children and families."
Recommendations will be made by the end of 2016.
http://www.gov.scot/Topics/People/Young-People/protecting/child-protection

Later in the year it was announced that as part of the Child Protection Improvement Programme: "an independent child protection review chaired by former Crown agent Catherine Dyer is to be commissioned in Scotland."

"This followed the conviction of a mother and her partner for the murder of her two-year-old son, Liam Fee."

"National outcry erupted over why the social work department allowed his case to slip through the system and failed to act upon concerns for the safety and welfare of the boy."

"Deputy First Minister John Swinney announced the appointment of Ms Dyer at a summit held in Perth."

"Mr Swinney said: `An essential part of the child protection improvement programme is a review of policy, practice, services and structures so that we can identify strengths, achievements and priorities for change`."

"`We will look at child protection committees, initial case reviews, significant case reviews and the child protection register to ensure that they work together to create a holistic, coherent and responsive child protection system that optimises outcomes for children`."

http://www.scottishlegal.com/2016/06/08/catherine-dyer-to-chair-child-protection-review/

Given what we know about Alan Small`s involvement in GIRFEC`s  implementation, i.e. named persons,  and his later appointment to Fife`s child protection committee, how much of a coherent and holistic response to a child protection review should we really be looking for ?

Perhaps a less joined up, less coherent approach, would be more reassuring.

Tuesday, 7 June 2016

Bodnariu family to be reunited


by Jayme Metzgar
 
"A child welfare case in Norway that has been grabbing headlines and stirring protests worldwide came to a sudden end late last week."

"The story... centres on Marius and Ruth Bodnariu and their five young children. Marius, a Romanian citizen, and Ruth, a native Norwegian, first ran afoul of Norway`s child protective services (called Barnevernet) in November 2015. After privately interviewing the family`s two oldest daughters at school, Barnevernet abruptly took all five children into emergency custody: First the girls, then the younger boys, and finally the three-month-old baby..."

"What began as one family`s harrowing story soon widened into an overall look at Bernevernet`s practices and raw power. Norwegian law grants enormous authority to local CPS offices, allowing them to seize children, place them in foster care, and even move to terminate parental rights, completely outside the framework of the judicial system and its rules of due process..."

"The Bodnarius’ story soon sparked anti-Barnevernet protests at Norwegian embassies and consulates around the world. While Norway defended itself in the press, the Bodnarius’ infant son, Ezekiel, was quietly returned to his parents this April. Still, the local CPS pushed forward with its plan to declare the four older children permanent wards of the state. A final set of hearingsbefore a non-judicial `County Social Welfare Board"began on May 30, 2016`."

"On Friday, June 3, the family website joyously announced the results of those hearings: Barnevernet had finally been forced to drop its case against Marius and Ruth Bodnariu, reaching an agreement to return their children. Because the case was dropped rather than ruled upon, there can be no appeal. After seven long months, Eliana, Naomi, Matthew, and John will finally come home..."

"While Norway’s defenders might point to this outcome as evidence that its system worked, Peter Costea, a Texas civil rights attorney who donated hundreds of pro bono hours to the case, vehemently disagrees. `The Norwegian system did not work,` he told me. `But for the international pressure on Norway, the children would not be home with their parents today. They would still be where they were back in November. I’m 101 percent certain of that`...."

"Donnelly* echoed the call for vigilance, and not only in Europe. `Regrettably, Norway is not alone,` he said. `Most western countries have CPS systems that are growing into bureaucracies that refuse to respect the family as the basic unit of society. Too many governments are too willing to traumatise children and families over minor disagreements`."

Read more http://thefederalist.com/2016/06/06/under-international-pressure-norway-reunites-seized-children-with-family/

*Mike Donnelly is director of global outreach for Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA)

Child protection warnings ignored in Fife

"MULTIPLE warnings about staff absence and other child protection dangers in Fife were repeatedly overlooked in the months before the murder of Liam Fee."

"Senior figures from Fife Council, NHS Fife, Police Scotland, the Scottish Government and children's charities were all made aware of the long-standing concerns."

"Yet, despite being the potential for `severe consequences` being made abundantly clear, the matter was simply batted back and forth between various panels for more than a year before the two-year-old's death."

"During the murder trial that horrified Scotland, Fife's child protection team manager Karen Pedder admitted Liam had `fallen off the radar` after his social worker went off sick on April 1, 2013."

"Just a few weeks later, on June 26, 2013, the Child Protection Committee discussed an `amber alert for child protection` that had been triggered by a `staff absence`..."

"The amber alert was also discussed by the Fife Chief Officer's Public Safety Group on the same day at the council headquarters in nearby Glenrothes."

"John Myles, the chairman of the CPC, again told the meeting it had been triggered by a `staff absence` and added: `This was a recording issue not an information sharing issue`."

"Ken Greer, chairman of Children in Fife, even warned `that it was important to remember that the cumulative effect of staff absence does impact on service provision`."

"Among those present were Fife Council chief executive Steve Grimmond, Police Scotland commander Garry McEwan and NHS Fife chief executive John Wilson."

"The alert was also flagged up to the Fife Partnership Board on August 28, 2013, when Scottish Government head of resilience Michael Kellet was in attendance."

"At a further meeting of the CPC on October 9, 2013, Fife's nursing director Dr Scott McLean said `that he had spoken to the Lead within Police Scotland and the Social Work lead and our arrangements around Child Protection are deemed safe`."

"However, the alert remained in place until December 2013, just three months before Liam was killed by a blow that ruptured his heart on March 22, 2014."

"In a terrible year for children in Fife, Mikaeel Kular, three, was beaten to death by his mother and his body dumped in woods in Kirkcaldy in January and Madison Horn, two, was murdered by her babysitter in Kelty in April."

"Incredibly, however, the minutes from 2014 show these three tragedies were never even considered by the Child Protection Committee."

"Instead, most of the time was spent discussing the Scottish Government's Girfec - or 'Getting it right for every child' - approach, including the Named Person for every under-18."

"Meanwhile, further evidences shows that yet another expert panel - NHS Fife's Clinical Governance Committee - was aware of child protection problems from at least December 2012."

"In April 2013, the committee members were told: `There is a risk the Child Protection systems and processes are not routinely updated, widely understood, used or adhered to by NHS Fife staff, potentially placing children at risk in Fife`."

"Chillingly, the papers also warned `the consequences of an incident occuring would be severe so the risk remains high`."

"In February 2014, just a few weeks before Liam's murder, Fife's lead child protection nurse revealed the `impact` of red tape created by the Girfec reforms."

"Fiona Lornie said: `Inter-agency Referral Discussions (IRDs) continue to have a significant impact on the workload of the Child Protection Nursing team despite an internal review and changes to processes. Whilst this is an important function of the team it also causes a delay in development of the Child Protection service`."

"Dr Gordon Macdonald, Parliamentary Officer for CARE for Scotland, said social work departments had borne the brunt of council spending cuts in recent years..."

"They have created a huge amount of extra work without resourcing it properly and the danger of making the haystack so big is that you don't catch the needle."

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/676898/warnings-regarding-child-protection-Fife-overlooked-before-Liam-Fee?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium

Friday, 3 June 2016

Did Liam Fee have a named person ?

As far as Jackie Brock, Chief Executive of Children in Scotland, is concerned:
"The named person service will help social work professionals by supporting children and young people early and diverting them from formal intervention. This will give social workers and their partners more time to work alongside families who need more support given their circumstances." 
http://thirdforcenews.org.uk/blogs/the-named-person-will-safeguard-children-from-abuse#Vu4PYP6Fx1vvkoEX.99 
 
It`s messages like that which give everybody the right to ask if Liam Fee, the little boy killed by his mother and her partner, had a named person. How else can people determine if the named person scheme is a help or a hindrance?

Not according to John Swinney, deputy First Minister.
"It is atrocious for critics of the controversial named person scheme to use the `utterly tragic` murder of Liam Fee to attack the Scottish Government’s policy, the Deputy First Minister has said."
"John Swinney, who has taken on the role of Education Secretary, insisted the death of the two-year-old at the hands of his mother and her civil partner` has absolutely nothing to do with named persons`."
 Absolutely nothing: yet according to one of the biggest supporters of the named person service, who is often quoted by the Scottish Government, it will give social workers and their partners more time to work alongside families. But that contradicts what we know about the Liam Fee case: a social worker went off sick and a little boy `fell off the radar.` That sounds more like a service starved of resources.

Kenneth Roy has written an excellent article on the same topic, stating that not only did Fife have the named person service in place "it was producing '400 cases per month’ as long ago as April 2013. Four hundred a month:"
"Think about it," he says. "In the small local authority of Fife, in the year before Liam Fee’s death, the council’s Named Persons were generating an annual caseload numbering almost 5,000 apparently without breaking sweat."
"Was Liam Fee part of that impossible caseload? We don’t know yet." 
http://www.scottishreview.net/KennethRoy54a.html
 

The moral high ground does not lie with those who would shut down the debate. The people of Scotland have a right to ask and a right to know.

See also: http://no2np.org/tough-questions-named-person-following-tragic-liam-fee-murder/

Wednesday, 1 June 2016

UK Column report on murder of Liam Fee


UK Column News reported on the murder of Liam Fee and the implications for the Named Person scheme and wider issues beginning around 41 minutes into the programme. Please note some of the detail of abuse suffered by Liam and the two other little boys is harrowing.

Brian Gerrish followed that up by pointing to a discussion on twitter which began with BBC Scotland asking if the Named Person scheme could help prevent cases like the murder of Liam Fee in the future.

Ruth Davidson MSP responded to the tweet by informing BBC Scotland that Liam Fee did have a Named Person under the Fife pilot scheme.

"There was then a massive attack."  For instance, somebody said: "You`re not using that poor child`s death as political capital are you? Tories wouldn`t do that."

"Well all Ruth Davidson was doing was telling the exact truth," says Gerrish. "and of course, in telling the truth that this little boy was under the Named Person scheme, what she is doing is absolutely highlighting that the Named Person scheme is complete rubbish and gives no child protection because, aside from anything else, the report goes back to the same failing social services in the first place."

Gerrish then questions Nicola Sturgeon`s honesty in her account of the Named Person. "She said it is not compulsory; but it is; it is compulsory to report on the child and family."

"I`m going to defend Nippy here," says Mike Robinson, "because this is a great example of why we`ve got to watch very carefully what politicians say because what Nippy said was it was not compulsory for the parents to take part in the Named Person scheme. But the parents have no part in the Named Person scheme. It`s a relationship between the Named Person and the child. That`s compulsory." 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVu2OrMSmdI 

 
I think we`ll make our own minds up about that.

Review announced into the tragic case of Liam Fee

From the Daily Star 1.6.2016:

"The SNP`s controversial Named Persons scheme `did nothing` to protect murdered tot Liam Fee, campaigners claim."

"Liam is the latest youngster to die despite having a state appointed guardian and also being known to social services."

"Liam`s childminder, nursery manager and family friends raised concerns with social workers on several occasions, while his health visitor - his Named Person under the scheme then being trialled by Fife Council - discussed her fears with the family GP."

"Despite all these warning signs, Liam`s case dropped `off the radar` when the social worker overseeing it went off sick on April 1, 2013."

"Just weeks before Liam`s death on March 22 2014, another two-year-old, Clyde Campbell, died of cot death in Inverness."

"He was repeatedly neglected by his mother Amanda Hardie and Highland Council also had the Named Person scheme in place at the time."

"The cases follow a number of other tragic deaths of youngsters in Scotland, including three-year-old Mikaeel Kular who was also know to social workers in Fife and Edinburgh before he was killed by his mother in January 2014."

===========
 
"A `thorough and comprehensive` review into the tragic case of Liam Fee has been announced by the authorities."

"After the guilty verdicts, Dougie Dunlop, vice chairman of Fife Child Protection Committee, said the review would reflect `to see whether there is any scope for improvement`."

Tuesday, 31 May 2016

Could anyone have saved Liam Fee ?

"One of the questions raised by the case of Liam Fee - whose mother and her partner were convicted of his murder - has been could anyone have saved him?"

"On a number of occasions concerns were raised about the little boy, who was only two-and-a-half-years old when he died."

"His nursery alerted social services, worried by a change in Liam, and the fact that he was losing weight and had a number of injuries."

"Liam's childminder had also made her concerns known."

"The High Court in Livingston heard from Patricia Smith, who used the same childminder. Ms Smith told the jury she phoned Fife Social Work department after meeting the Fees in the street."

"Liam was in his buggy but she told the court she didn't know if he was drugged or dead."

"A senior Fife social worker admitted in court that at one point Liam `fell off their radar`. A member of staff had gone off sick, no-one else was assigned and Liam's case was not reviewed until further concerns were raised."

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-36397785

"Det Insp Rory Hamilton, of Police Scotland, said: `During joint interviews with specially-trained detectives and officials from Fife Council, the evidence began to build towards a picture of horrendous abuse which directly contributed to the version of events being put forward by the two accused being utterly discredited`."

"`This was a complex, challenging and sensitive investigation which involved interviewing two young children to establish the level of abuse and neglect both they and Liam Fee had been subjected to`."

"`It was because of their courage that detectives were able to identify Rachel and Nyomi Fee as being responsible for a wide range of serious offences against three children`."

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-36417415

From (GIRFEC) Programme Board minutes (page 4) [10.09.2013]
"Alan offered an example of good practice on information sharing from Fife. Fife already had the Named Person in place and the police had been sharing information since April 2013. 400 cases per month had been raised."
http://www.gov.scot/resource/0044/00441605.pdf

Liam died in a bedroom of the family home on Saturday 22 March 2014. There had been several warnings to child protection services, but his Named Person did not save him.

Despite Humza Yousaf`s statement on Question Time about the dangers of misconceptions about the Name Person scheme, the biggest misconception is that the scheme will prevent such abuses.

It`s time to throw out the GIRFEC wellbeing data grab and start investing more in child protection social services who need to be properly trained, focused and resourced.

Council forced to issue apology for medical mix-up

Former nursery school headteacher Angela Milnes was distraught when council officials wrongly labelled her as mentally ill and threatened to have her young daughter Sylvia (pictured, now aged seven) adopted
"A former nursery school headteacher has told how bungling social workers put her three-year-old daughter into care for eight months after a medical record mix-up."

"Angela Milnes was distraught when council officials wrongly labelled her as mentally ill and threatened to have Sylvia adopted."

"The award-winning parenting blogger had to fight to get her daughter back before council bosses finally admitted they had made a mistake."

"Eventually, a judge ordered mother and daughter to be reunited and council chiefs were forced to issue an apology. They also agreed to pay Mrs Milnes substantial damages, which must be held in trust until Sylvia, now seven, turns 18."

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3615575/Girl-care-eight-months-social-worker-error.html#ixzz4AGUYGNmT

Wednesday, 25 May 2016

Parents arrested for leaving children alone for short periods

"Parents who leave 15-year-old children alone for short periods are being arrested on suspicion of neglect, it has emerged."

"While the majority of cases involve infants, figures obtained under the Freedom of Information Act, have revealed that some of those involved are as old as 15."

"At the moment law on the issue is vague with legislation simply stating that a parent or guardian can be prosecuted if they leave a child unsupervised in a manner like to cause unnecessary suffering or injury to health."

"There is no mention of what age it is deemed safe to leave a young person alone, so when matters are reported it is often left up to the individual officer to make a decision on whether to take action."

"With police action usually triggering intervention from the social services, campaigners are demanding more clarity so parents know where they stand."

-----------------------------------

"In 2004 Tim Haines from Worcestershire was arrested and charged with neglect after leaving his two-year-old daughter in his car for five minutes as he popped into a chemist."

"He was subsequently convicted at magistrate's court and faced a lengthy battle to stop his five children being taken into care."

"He eventually had the conviction overturned on appeal."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/12193955/Parents-of-15-year-olds-arrested-for-leaving-them-unattended.html

Wednesday, 18 May 2016

New laws will encourage adoption

"The government is to pass new laws to encourage adoption in a bid to improve the chances of children in social care in England, David Cameron has said."

"Writing in the Sunday Times, the PM promised `zero tolerance` of state failure around social care and a new covenant for those leaving care."

"New laws will encourage the permanent adoption of children, even when it overrides family ties, he added."

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-36295213?SThisFB


Researching Reform has discovered a piece of research that suggests a more cautious approach to permanence should be implemented.

https://researchingreform.net/

Andreia`s battle to regain her children

Londra_Andreia-Sutton-Bardeanu-cu-copiii-ei
 
Diaspora Românească, April 26th, 2016

"In 2009 a UK judge decided to take away her children. Andreia has ever since struggled to get them back. She says she was humiliated, threatened and even arrested for just trying to get a glimpse of her kids. British authorities required her not to talk publicly about her case if she ever wants to see them again."
"But, after widespread international support for Bodnariu family, who also have Romanian ties and who have been going through the same ordeal in Sweden*, Andreia decided her only hope is that the rest of the world finds out about her nightmare... "

"Andreia has tried to get them back but with no success. She has tearfully declared to Diaspora Românească: `These professionals said themselves that my husband was dangerous, lying and manipulative, but they did not take into account the fact that I was also one of his victims. I paid for my own psychological counselling sessions. My counsellor wrote a favourable report on my progress and my ability to protect my children. But this report, as many others, was not taken into account by the court of law when I asked to be given back my children. In the meantime I remarried a young man my own age who loves me and understands me. He stood by me in my fight to regain custody of my children. Both my husband Alex and me have proven we have everything needed to raise these children. But each time we met with the authorities’ refusal`."
 
"The girls were put into an English family. The boy was taken to an orphanage, where he suffered physical and emotional abuse from the older boys. `The law says my boy should not have been taken to that place, because he was too young. He was harassed and his behaviour was negatively impacted, but the police say there is no sufficient evidence. He was just recently moved to the care of a man who really takes care of him. I have all the respect for this man who helps my child, he’s a true man`, added Andreia."
 
http://familynews.ro/excessive-enforcement-by-uk-child-protection-officials-has-deprived-romanian-mother-of-her-three-kids/

*Not Sweden, but Norway

Monday, 16 May 2016

Social workers failed to challenge independent report

"A failure to challenge an independent social worker’s report was a key error in a case where a father beat his four-year-old daughter to death after she was sent to live with him."

"The serious case review into the murder of Alexa-Marie Quinn, called Sophie in the report, found social workers in Bedford were confused about the status and function of the court-ordered report and so did not challenge it."

"Social workers also felt unable to delay the case when new concerns emerged because the care proceedings had already exceeded the 26-week target for cases to be decided."

"Bedford Council put Quinn and her siblings into foster care in March 2012 due to their mother’s chaotic lifestyle, substance misuse and domestic violence at home."

"When care proceedings began Quinn’s father, Carl Wheatley who lived in Hertfordshire, said he wanted to be his daughter’s carer. While assessments of his suitability took place, contact was established between him and his daughter for the first time since shortly after her birth..."

"The court appointed an independent social worker to assess Wheatley’s parenting capacity."

"But the letter of instruction for the independent social worker’s report did not include all the concerns raised in Bedford’s initial assessment of Wheatley despite being approved by social services and the Cafcass children’s guardian."

http://www.communitycare.co.uk/2016/05/13/failure-challenge-independent-social-worker-report-key-error-case-dad-beat-four-year-old-daughter-death/

It was only going to be a matter of time before the 26 week target was going to cause serious problems.

Monday, 9 May 2016

Social worker struck off register after relationship with vulnerable boy

 
"A social worker has been struck off the register after engaging in a sexual relationship with a 'vulnerable' teenage boy."

"Claire Runkee, 38, was struck off the register of social workers after her relationship with the 16-year-old, during which she took him to a hotel for the night and sent him a string of explicit messages."

"At a Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC) hearing it emerged the boy - who was placed with his foster carers at the age of four and known as Child A - had to undergo therapy after the liaison was uncovered."

"Ms Runkee was caught when the boy's foster carers saw more than 100 'graphic and sexually explicit' messages on Facebook."

"She qualified as a social worker in 2012, and had been working with a children's safeguarding team for a year before developing 'a friendship' outside of work with Child A."

"The boy was vulnerable, had struggled at school and was under a care order."

"His foster carers saw the Facebook messages from Ms Runkee between January 1 and February 13 last year, which showed she had 'placed pressure' on the boy not to reveal their relationship."

Read more:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3576664/Social-worker-38-sex-vulnerable-boy-16-hotel-sending-string-100-graphic-sexually-explicit-messages-Facebook.html#ixzz487JZQxAz

Saturday, 7 May 2016

Big data and predictive analytics

 
"For some parents, the words `Child Protective Services` send chills down the spine. In an effort to stamp out fraud and abuse, welfare outfits across the country have honed in on poor communities of color for decades now, critics claim, with almost any government interaction potentially leading to kids being removed from their homes."

"Now big data is set [to] make the dynamic even more intenseand racially charged."

"In 1999, the foster care population in the United States reached a peak at 567,000. But due to both diminishing budgets and programs aimed at keeping children in their homes, that number dropped to 415,000 by 2014. The representation of black children in the foster system remains disproportionately high, however: Black children account for 24 percent of kids in foster care, while comprising just 14 percent of the general population of children in the US. And a burgeoning method for determining exactly which families get visits from child welfare caseworkers has advocates for low-income families worried the disparity will only get worse."

"The new approach is called `predictive analytics,` and it's taking the child welfare system by storm. Across the country, from suburban counties in Florida to major cities like Los Angeles, child welfare agencies are launching initiatives that take data points like race, parental welfare status, and criminal history, and a variety of other publicly available characteristics, and feed them into an algorithm that assigns each child a `risk` score. That score is then considered when determining whether a caseworker should visit a family."